November 17, 2026

From 28 players to 1.8 million: what Probably Stolen teaches us

Clare Hawkins, Strategic Marketing Director

What does it take to turn a demo that peaked at 28 players into one of this year’s biggest indie launches?

In the case of Probably Stolen – Cyberpunk Shopkeeper Sim, the answer is roughly 1.8 million copies and $20 million in its first 12 days on Steam, according to GameDiscoverCo estimates.

The game sold around 350,000 copies on day one and was still selling more than 200,000 copies per day a week and a half later.

At least in part, the success seems based on a run of good decisions, each providing learnings for other studios.

A second life for a quiet idea

The game started as Deepspace Emporium, from Montreal’s Questing Goose Studio. Its 2025 demo peaked at just 28 concurrent players. Many projects would have stalled there. Instead, tinyBuild saw something in the concept.

CEO Alex Nichiporchik says the publisher “worked with the dev to reinvent the visuals and focus on what works”. The setting and core loop of running a shop where stock is morally questionable stayed. The look, focus and name changed.

‍

Back to Insights

‍

The new name was a shrewd move. Cyberpunk Shopkeeper Sim immediately tells a browsing player exactly what they are getting. Players then gave it their own shorthand: Papers, Please meets shop management. That comparison appears repeatedly in reviews; a marketeer’s dream.

Two showcases, a month apart

The run-up to launch seemed textbook. In mid-September the game appeared at tinyBuild Connect and added around 66,000 wishlists, the biggest gain of any of the 16 games shown. In October, it entered Steam Next Fest and gained a further 131,000 wishlists. That was the largest increase of all 7,319 games in the event.

The demo carried that momentum, going live about a month before release and played by approximately 660,000-700,000 people, with 98% positive reviews. Wishlists climbed from around 480,000 in mid-October to 657,000 on launch day.

Next Fest ending a week before release meant the excitement went straight into sales rather than fading over months of waiting. And the launch has kept building: daily sales picked up again over the second weekend, which points to word of mouth and creators extending the tail. Wishlists are still rising too, past 900,000, which leaves a large pool of buyers for the first discount.

‍

Back to Homepage

China: finding its audience

The most striking detail is where the players are. Probably Stolen has more than twice as many Simplified Chinese reviews (around 9,300) as English (around 4,000), and GameDiscoverCo suggests roughly two-thirds of owners are in China.

Its audience also overlaps heavily with players of indie management and survival games popular in China, such as Card Survival, Survival Log and Doloc Town.

Streaming tells a similarly international story. Its biggest Twitch channels are Japanese, Taiwanese and Spanish-speaking, alongside Western management-game streamers.

‍

See also: Bastion America

Follow Bastion on LinkedIn or subscribe to our Weekly News Digest.

What other studios can learn

An underperforming demo is not always a clear verdict. Deepspace Emporium’s numbers indicated a weak market response. A sharper look, a clearer focus and a better name proved otherwise. If the core loop is good, the packaging may be the problem.

Put the hook in the name. A title that explains the genre, plus a comparison players are happy to repeat, makes everything else work harder.

Phased marketing. A publisher showcase, followed by a polished Next Fest demo and launch soon after. Each step fed the next, wasting no momentum.

Take China seriously. Careful localisation and regional pricing aren’t extras, and translation quality shows up directly in your review score.

Some more insights

Bastion Weekly News Digest

For more expert insight and analysis of all the latest news in the games industry, subscribe to the Bastion Weekly News Digest on Substack.
Subscribe now
arrow_forward
‍
Abstract rendering of the orange logo on a blue background.

Ready to reach a new audience?

Tell My Story
north